If you’ve done even an ounce of reading on the subject of interviewing, you’ve probably come across a frequently recommended approach called the STAR method which encourages job hunters to break down their interview “example” stories into a series of four logical parts: 1) The Situation you faced; 2) the Task you had to complete; 3) the Actions you took; and 4) the Results you achieved.
On the whole, this formula makes a lot of sense and is designed not only to help job seekers avoid delivering their answers in a rambling and unstructured way, but also to ensure one’s responses contain interesting storytelling elements and lots of juicy detail to pique the interest of the hiring manager. And if you’re not familiar with the STAR concept, simply Google the term and you’ll literally find hundreds of articles talking about it.
In actual practice, however, I’ve found that the STAR method can actually be a bit of “fool’s gold” in terms of how job applicants apply it. In many of the mock interviews I conduct with clients, I see people attempt to use the 4-step formula and it either backfires or falls flat. So again, while the general concept of the approach makes a ton of sense, keep in mind these additional considerations if you plan on using the STAR framework yourself:
1) The examples can sound over-rehearsed
While prepping examples prior to interviews is a very wise thing to do, you don’t want to draft/rehearse your answers to such an intense degree that they sound “canned” or lacking in spontaneity. For example, in many interviews I’ll ask a question like “Can you tell me about a time you showed initiative?” and in less than two nanoseconds, the candidate starts reciting a robotic-sounding story that is so clearly built around the four STAR segments (worse yet, some people actually call out the name of each section!) that it just seems, well, weird. So while there’s nothing wrong with organizing your answers in this manner, try not to be too obvious about the fact that you’re following a “formula” and don’t memorize every word in advance. Simply flesh out the high-level points you want to cover, then focus on weaving them together in an impromptu and fresh manner each time you deliver them. The goal is to sound thoughtful, professional, and well-organized — not like you’re reading a script!
2) It can lead people to answer the wrong question
Another danger of using the STAR method, I’ve found, is that people get so locked in and waiting for a certain question to come up that they fail to hear the actual question that was asked. In a recent interview role-playing session I conducted, for instance, I had a client who had prepared extensively to deliver a STAR example in response to the question “Can you tell me about a time that you worked effectively across department lines?” So when the time came, and I asked a question about working on a cross-functional basis, she diligently recited her pre-planned answer in all of its glory. The problem? The question I asked didn’t call for an example. Instead, I had asked her to “share some insights” on the keys to working effectively across departments, so when she launched into a long story about a project she had worked on once upon a time, it totally missed the mark. It was obvious she had just been waiting for the chance to blurt out a pre-programmed story without really paying attention to what I (as the interviewer) actually wanted to know.
So again, if you’re a disciple of the STAR method, make sure you listen closely to each question asked by the hiring manager and only provide examples when the hiring manager specifically requests such a thing. If their question starts with “Tell me about a time you…” or “Can you walk me through an example where you…”, you’re golden. But beyond that, a STAR example usually isn’t called for and will seem really out of place.
3) The “Actions” part can be easily abused
In general, when giving answers in an interview, there are few cases when you’d want your response to be more than 2-3 minutes in length. If you go beyond that limit, there’s a very strong likelihood you’re going to exceed the attention span of the interviewer — and/or potentially frustrate them by eating up valuable time during which they were hoping to ask other questions on their agenda.
In almost every case, the part of the STAR method that leads peoples’ answers to violate the length limit is the “Actions” part. Many interview candidates seem compelled to walk through each and every granular detail of the story/project in question — which can easily lead to answers that run 4-5 minutes or more in length. In truth, the hiring manager (most likely) doesn’t really care about the specific project you tackled and every single detail that went into it. Instead, their interest is going to be centered on the overarching theme of the question and how you applied the specific strength at hand in a successful way. So when practicing your STAR stories, time yourself, and if you routinely find yourself going beyond the 2-3 minute mark, the best solution is almost always going to be trim out some fat from the “actions” part.
4) It can suck the life out of the conversation
Last but not least, and perhaps the aspect of the STAR method I find the most problematic, is the fact that it can easily coerce job candidates into thinking of interviews as more of a “Q&A session” or a “test” rather than an actual two-way human conversation. When asked about a time you “dealt effectively with ambiguity” for example, you don’t necessarily need to immediately launch into a structured example. It’s okay to think for a minute and engage in a bit of chit-chat about the question before diving headfirst into your story.
On this note, I typically encourage people to go beyond the main STAR structure and also put conversational “bookends” around their answers. Before launching into a story about a particular strength, in other words, first acknowledge the question in some way. Agree on the importance of the skill in question. Share an interesting insight about it. Have a laugh. Or even just pause and look thoughtful for a second before delivering your answer. Then, once your STAR story is finished, don’t suddenly just stop talking and stare awkwardly back at the person across the desk. Restate or re-acknowledge the question that was asked, inquire (once in a while) whether your example answered the question successfully, and again, share a final remark or two about the competency you were asked about.
In other words, treat the interview as a normal conversation and allow some natural transition in and out of your STAR examples. Otherwise, again, it will sound like you’re just reading from a set of cue cards and you’ll miss the chance to build some valuable rapport with the person across the desk.
In closing, I know some of these observations might seem picky, but they can be make-or-break factors in real hiring situations where “cultural fit” and “chemistry” factors count every bit as much as one’s actual job competencies. And again, don’t misunderstand me, I truly think the STAR method is a helpful tool in preparing for interviews. Just make sure to avoid taking it too far — or relying so heavily on the framework as a crutch — that it blinds you from actually listening to the hiring manager or allowing some natural, normal dialogue to take place!
Great advice Matt. I especially like your advice in #4 to treat the interview like a conversation. (As if you already work with the interviewer.) I like when people provide a shorter answer and ask if I want more information or ask if this was what I was looking for. Giving a 30 minute answer that sounds like a rehearsed homework assignment is tough. I really dislike cutting people off and sharing that I have more questions to get through. Interviewing can be tough and SMART with your bookends is perfect!
I completely agree with your insights, Matt! Keeping the interview like a normal conversation feels so much better. I think it allows the candidate to start establishing the dynamics with the hiring manager, if they happen to be the one selected for the position. The Q&A format feels way too one-sided.
As the hiring manager I recently have seen all four of these pit falls absolutely compromise the candidates prospects, more than once. My basic advice, know when to stop talking, allowing the interviewer to move on.