When people ask me what’s different about job hunting today than in days past, there are a great many things I could call out.
Honestly, though, I think one of the most insidious changes that’s taken place is the notion that having one resume isn’t good enough anymore and that you need to carefully customize it for every single job to which you apply.
You’ll find this advice everywhere. Career coaches say to do it. Recruiters say to do it. AI tools say to do it. And the vast majority of online discussion forums about job hunting are also full of people recommending this approach and acting like this is the big secret to supercharging your resume results.
For example, if I ask Google Gemini whether resume customization is important, it cheerfully implores “Yes, absolutely. Customizing your resume—often called tailoring—is one of the most effective ways to increase your interview callback rate.”
Then there’s this quote from a recent CNBC article, “It’s a job seeker’s best bet,” says Brie Weiler Reynolds, senior career specialist at job search website FlexJobs. “I’ve heard the same advice over and over from recruiters who spend their days reviewing resumes looking for the best candidates.”
On top of this, the website CVBuilder claims that “Studies show that tailored resumes receive a 40% higher response rate compared to generic ones.” and the grassroots discussion site Reddit has scores of people saying things like:
“Honestly, customizing your resume can hugely boost your interview chances because it helps you pass the ATS filters and catches the hiring manager’s eye.”
“I believe it’s the only way to get noticed. You have to be 100% match + apply early and/or know someone at the company to get an interview these days.”
“Tailoring your resume for each application is super important. Highlighting the skills and experiences that match the job description really helps you get past ATS and catch a recruiter’s eye. It might take some extra time, but it’s definitely worth it for better results.”
All of this being said, however, there’s a growing wave of pushback out there questioning whether this highly touted “best practice” actually makes much difference at the end of the day. You’ll find some good counterarguments in articles such as the ones here, here, and here if interested in learning more.
Ultimately, though, many job hunters are reporting that it’s costing them many extra hours a week to review and tweak every single resume before they send it out — and that on top of that, it can be a nightmare to organize all the different versions and remember which document you might have sent to one employer, versus another.
So where do I stand on all this, having watched the phenomenon grow from being a rarely practiced technique to a mainstream, you’re-an-idiot-if-you-don’t-do-it necessity in recent years?
As with most things, I think the optimal answer lies somewhere in the middle. While I don’t think it’s time well spent for the average job hunter to devote hours each day to the resume personalization process, it’s hard to argue against taking 5-10 minutes to quickly tweak a few keywords and the opening summary of the resume, if needed, to align more closely with the position at hand.
So if you’re spending more time than that on a per-application basis, my advice would be to:
- Ensure your resume is set up in a modular way that allows you to easily drag-and-drop new information into the file without screwing up the format or needing to rewrite entire passages
- Utilize any of the common AI tools to quickly personalize your presentation to a given role, but make sure you review the results carefully to avoid hallucinations and inaccurate additions
- If you’re a Career Horizons client, use the AI-driven resume customization tool on our website to tailor your materials, which not only preserves your document’s format but flags all of the AI changes made for quick and easy review before sending
Again, I’m monitoring the landscape closely to see if we reach a tipping point where the majority of recruiters get burned out on overly personalized documents and claim they’d rather see an organic, untailored resume versus one that’s clearly been adjusted to perfectly match the specialized role at hand.
I don’t think we’re there yet, but the noise around this issue seems to be growing…
Leave A Comment