Interview Deception: Realities & Ways to Combat It

/, Negotiating/Interview Deception: Realities & Ways to Combat It

Interview Deception: Realities & Ways to Combat It

Several months ago, I came across an article that I’ve been meaning to write about ever since — given that it deals with a common issue in today’s job market, involving situations when hiring managers actively mislead employees about the role they’re considering or the culture/morale within an organization.

In this case, however, somebody decided to actually do something about it.  See the article below, where a top executive at the Gates Foundation decided to sue the company based on a claim they misled him about the nature of the assignment.

https://www.geekwire.com/2017/former-bill-melinda-gates-executive-sues-organization-claims-misled-role/#disqus_thread

Now I’m not sure about you, but based on the facts shared in this article, I must confess I have little sympathy for this individual’s position — and should he somehow be successful with his legal challenge, I’d encourage the majority of the American workforce to lawyer up and look for a similar payday.  Simply put, job descriptions change.  Quickly.  And the needs of assignments today, almost by definition, are going to morph, grow, and evolve constantly based on the changing needs an organization is forced to deal with.  Any expectation that you’re going to walk into a job knowing exactly what’s expected or what challenges you’re going to face is, frankly, naive.

So when it comes to somebody asking for millions of dollars simply because he felt the interviewing process didn’t accurately depict the opportunity in question, I agree with one of the comments underneath the article that observed:

“Priorities change at any organization. You’re an asset if you’re flexible. This lawsuit almost seems unreal. Clashing with other employees? Your role changing direction? The role being different than what you’d hoped for? Please! Welcome to the workforce.”

In fact, given what I’ve observed dealing with thousands of people interviewing for new positions, I’d say that it’s almost more of the rule — rather than the exception — that a candidate receives only partial clarity about a given job opportunity before accepting it.  Along the same lines, it’s also probably a safe bet to say that most job candidates exaggerate their credentials, overstate their accomplishments, or gloss over some of their past failures to at least some degree when pitching themselves, in return.  Everybody puts their best foot forward, right or wrong, and neither side is entering into the new relationship with full and complete information

This being said, for those who have suffered through situations where the reality of the job turned out to be a far cry from the promised potential — and who want to do as much due diligence as possible to avoid future surprises — here are a few potential tips for consideration:

  • Track down online reviews about the company via sites like Glassdoor, Careerbliss, and Fairygodboss.com (rankings of companies by women, for women) to see if there are any telling and consistent comments regarding the culture, hiring process, and/or management team
  • Conduct thorough research into the company’s current operations via obvious sites like Google, as well as deep-dive databases such as ProQuest and Factiva available through your local library; also set up a Google Alert on the company’s name to track breaking news and extremely recent developments
  • Pay attention to how you’re being treated in the hiring process; is the process running smoothly/professionally or is it plagued by missed appointments, sketchy details, bullying behavior, and other warning signs that might give you a hint of the situation you’d be walking into?
  • Observe other employees you encounter at the company, such as the reception staff, to see if they seem genuinely relaxed and happy — or instead give off vibes of being stressed, micromanaged, or marginalized
  • Use LinkedIn to track down people who used to work at the employer in question and consider reaching out to them (often through a mutual friend) to see if they can shed any light on what it’s like to work for the organization or some of the key leaders involved
  • Last but not least, and especially if your intuition is telling you the interviewer might be doing a “sales job” on you and omitting some important details, don’t be afraid to ask some pointed (but polite) questions regarding the history of the position, the expectations, the tenure/morale of the team, the potential risks involved, and similar matters — or even to ask to speak to other members of the staff before making your final decision

Again, no job offer situation is foolproof and an unscrupulous recruiter or manager can certainly still try to pull the wool over your eyes — and withhold key details about an opportunity and what it involves — but generally, using the above methods, you should be able to sniff out the cases where something is really off base.

Even then, though, should you find yourself in a situation like the executive above and discover that the circumstances of the job don’t match what you expected, I doubt you’ll have grounds for legal recourse.  That seems like far too slippery of a slope for the courts to want to monkey with.  So just move on, learn from the experience, and get even better about asking questions and conducting research the next time around.

Agree?  Disagree?  Any good (or bad) stories out there about how a hiring manager might have bamboozled you about an opportunity — or about how the responsibilities of your job changed dramatically, on the fly?

 

By | 2017-07-19T19:09:08+00:00 July 19th, 2017|Interviewing, Negotiating|4 Comments

About the Author:

4 Comments

  1. Linda Baker July 20, 2017 at 4:17 pm

    Fitting into a culture can make or break success anywhere and my philosophy is that you need to try and access that when you are going through the interviewing process. Great idea to reach out to past employees and also to request time with current employees to ask questions to learn about the “real company image/operations”. Would suggest asking -What are things that you learned about after you hired in, that were not apparent when you were interviewing? Tell me what traits the people who do well here possess?

  2. Mark Trotter July 20, 2017 at 7:07 pm

    Reading the facts presented in the filing (clearly the Plaintiff’s point of view), if he can substantiate the claims, he is very likely to win. What is not discussed is the firing of the CIO before the Plaintiff arrived and how he dealt with that obvious gap. On the surface, it does appear he was set up to fail in a highly politicized situation. Yes, we all find the job different than we expected. That said, there is a line that may have been crossed where the position is different enough from what was agreed to or represented that there are grounds for the suit. His career is definitely adversely impacted.

    • Matt Youngquist July 20, 2017 at 8:18 pm

      Mark: Appreciate the comment and must confess, after further review, I agree that perhaps this individual has a stronger legal case than I’d initially anticipated — since you’re right, there are certain gray areas and “levels of deception” that could potentially be involved in these situations. And his might be a more extreme case than most. At the same time, of course, the general notion that one is walking into any job with a full picture of what it entails — or that it won’t change — is the piece that I was most trying to focus on. You’re right, though. There may be more legs to this case than I’d initially assumed, given the general tone of the article…

  3. chrisenglin July 21, 2017 at 5:43 pm

    I’ve been following this as well and honestly, I’m surprised he didn’t anticipate some of these changes. On a similar note, I’ve noticed that time spent interviewing with hiring managers has decreased in many cases. Plus shorter interview loops. People are busy and trying to move faster. At any level, I believe it’s appropriate to ask to talk with someone again when receiving an offer. In fact, I often set this up. It’s a completely different discussion after you have the offer to learn more about what you will be doing, explore the relationship with who you will be working for or who you will be managing. If a company won’t talk with you again, then that says something as well.

Comments are closed.